Switching food production
in the UK to organic would mean major reductions in output - but not as big as
some might think, claims a new report.
In fact the study,
carried out by Reading University's Centre for Agricultural Strategy for the
organic Soil Association suggests such a move would cause a shift in "the
commodity mix" and as a result lead to people eating more healthily.
The Soil Association says
the findings show that organic farming has much to offer and could be
"mainstream agriculture in waiting".
Key benefits of a switch
to organic farming methods claimed by the report include:
* Cuts in greenhouse gas emissions and
water pollution A fall in energy intensive inputs to farming would fall, with
fertilizer inputs cut by 95% and sprays by 98%
* Jobs in the countryside would increase,
including a 73% increase in farm employment
* As organic fruit and vegetable yields
compare favourably with conventional agriculture, organic farming could, with
some adjustment, supply similar volumes as at present, or even increase output
if necessary
* Due to the need to abolish intensive pig
and poultry systems in organic agriculture, chicken, egg and pig meat
production would fall to roughly a quarter of current levels, making large
quantities of grain available for human consumption
The report concedes that
dairy production would fall by around 30%-40%, unless herds were to be
re-established and dairies were to re-open in parts of the country which have
lost them.
And it says the amount of
wheat and barley produced would fall by around 30% due to lower yields but
because far less grain would be fed to animals there could be as much wheat and
barley available for human consumption under an organic system as there is at
present.
"A wholly organic
agriculture could actually produce more beef and lamb than at present, with
beef production rising by 68% and lamb by 55%," says the report.
Soil Association policy
director Peter Melchett concedes that ?organic farming "does not have all
the answers to the challenges of climate change and diet related
ill-health" and admits there is "still a lot of work to do to improve
organic systems".
But he claims the report,
England and Wales under organic agriculture: how much food could be produced?
shows the positive impact that organic farming could have.
"In the face of the
rising prices and scarcity of key fossil fuel and mineral inputs, and the need
to cut greenhouse gas emissions 80% by 2050, food and farming systems will have
to go through revolutionary changes in the next few decades," says Lord
Melchett.
"The rapidly escalating diet related health crisis means that our diets are also going to have to change dramatically. This independent report shows that organic farming could provide us with a far healthier and much more climate friendly diet."